| Rank | Name | Score |
|---|---|---|
| #1 | Baba Louie's Sourdough Pizza
Great Barrington, MA |
95 |
| #2 | Pie for the People!
Joshua Tree, CA |
93 |
| #3 | Speedy Romeo
Brooklyn, NY |
92 |
| #4 | OTTO
Portland, ME |
90 |
| #5 | Olee's Master Pizza
Farmington, CT |
86 |
| #6 | Sgt. Pepperoni
Storrs, CT |
85 |
| #7 | Barb's Pizza
West Hartford, CT |
84 |
| #8 | Veggie Crust (Kosher)
Brookline, MA |
83 |
| #9 | Dino's Pizzeria
West Hartford, CT |
83 |
| #10 | Mulberry Street Pizza
Manchester, CT |
82 |
